This afternoon the Fed released what was widely characterized as a "dovish" statement. In response the all important 2-year note rallied by 2 basis points, the 10-year note closed just below 2% and the dollar declined modestly. All of this is consistent with the dovish tone of the Fed's statement.
However stocks sold off sharply with the S&P 500 down 1.1%. What gives? The answer is simple. All too many stock market participants continue to believe that Janet Yellen is their fairy godmother. They expected the Fed to be even more dovish. I hate to disabuse them of that notion but nowhere in the Federal Reserve Act does it say the Fed was put on this earth to support the stock market.
Meantime it looks like a March Fed Funds hike is off the table, but given the good data that I expect, June will be a very real possibility.
Wednesday, January 27, 2016
Monday, January 25, 2016
My Amazon Review of Niall Ferguson's "Kissinger: 1923-1968: The Idealist"
The Rise of Henry Kissinger
Niall Ferguson’s authorized biography
ends with Henry Kissinger’s appointment as national security advisor to Richard
Nixon in late 1968. Given the controversy that followed it is hard to believe
today that his appointment was nearly universally acclaimed by both the Left
and the Right. That appointment was a dramatic move up for an Orthodox Jewish
kid from Furth, Germany, whose family fled Nazi oppression in 1938.
Kissinger’s family established their household
in the Washington Heights section of Manhattan. Something must have been in the
water because out of that neighborhood came Allan Greenspan and my ex-boss at
Salomon Brothers, Henry Kaufman. Had not World War II intervened, Kissinger was
on his way to becoming an accountant.
The army changes him. He sees combat at
the Battle of the Bulge, witnesses first- hand the horrors of the Nazi
concentration camps and as a sergeant in the counter intelligence corps he
works after the war to round up Nazis that have gone to ground. Along the way
he leaves his orthodox faith. My guess is that is seeing the violence of the
front in World War II enabled him 20 years later to risk is life visiting the
war zones of 1965 Vietnam. Not much has been written about his physical
courage. Further during his first visit he realized that the Vietnam War was
unwinnable and a negotiated settlement was required.
Through some lucky breaks and an active
mentor Kissinger ends up in Harvard and it is in undergraduate years he becomes
an idealist in the Kantian sense. He truly believes in democracy and human
choice. He goes on to his Ph.D. and writes a very remarkable dissertation on the
Congress of Vienna and its aftermath which is later published as “A World
Restored.” Although not as famous as Keynes’s “Economic Consequences…” about
Versailles, he offers a unique insight into the geopolitics of 1815 Europe and
the key roles of Metternich and Castlereagh. One can certainly argue that this
book offered a window into Kissinger’s later thinking the 1970s with respect to
U.S. policy concerning Russia and China. Where he appears to lose his idealism
is in seeing up close how policy is really made and the machinations of De
Gaulle and the North Vietnamese. He begins to merge Castlereagh with Bismarck
to form the foundations of the “realpolitik” that he would become known for.
Kissinger becomes a public figure in
1957 with his publication of “Nuclear Weapons and Foreign Policy” which places
him in the center of the post-Sputnik foreign policy debate. From there it on
to both Kennedy’s National Security Council and the Rockefeller Brothers think
tank. Ferguson demonstrates Kissinger’s
adroitness in balancing his loyalties to both the Democrat Kennedy and the
Republican Rockefeller. After leaving the administration he works as
Rockefeller’s leading foreign policy wonk writing most of his speeches. He is
horrified by the 1964 Republican Convention which brought back memories of
1930s Furth and goes on to vote for Lyndon Johnson over Barry Goldwater.
Ferguson highlights the importance of
history to the making of foreign policy. Too many practitioners are unaware of
the path dependence of the irrevocable decisions they make. He also rightly
believes that Kissinger is correct that in analyzing policy it is important to
look at the counter factuals. For example had Britain and France stopped Hitler
in the Rhineland they likely would have avoided World War II, but they could
very well have been blamed for whatever events transpired later. Statesmen have
to act with incomplete information, because when you have full information it
is too late.
We also see Kissinger as a man with his
relationships with his parents, his less than happy marriage and his dog Smokey.
In my opinion Ferguson has set the stage for his next volume, where we will see
the Kissinger that most of us know, become quite a bit more controversial, to
say the least.
For the full Amazon URL see:
Labels:
Congress of Vienna,
foreign policy,
Germany,
Goldwater,
Harvard,
Johnson,
Kennedy,
Nazi,
Nixon,
Rockefeller,
Vietnam War
Thursday, January 7, 2016
Trump and the Stock Market: Connect the Dots
Since the start of the year the Chinese stock market has fallen out of bed and that has led to a worldwide fall in stock prices. According to the commentariat the reason for China collapse has to do with a growth slowdown in China, a devaluation of the Yuan and a relaxation of the restrictions on stock sales by large shareholders.
However something more fundamental maybe at work. Perhaps the Chinese market is now pricing in a Trump victory and with that the potential to wreak havoc with the global trading system. Should that happen the biggest loser would be China, but that would blow-back to the entire global economy. Not a pretty picture. Moreover with Hillary Clinton now opposed to the TPP the outlook for trade expansion is far from favorable.
Too many people I know joke about Trump, but the fact remains has consistently led the GOP field and he has to be viewed as having at least a 50/50 shot of getting the nomination. We may not pay attention, but the rest of the world certainly is.
However something more fundamental maybe at work. Perhaps the Chinese market is now pricing in a Trump victory and with that the potential to wreak havoc with the global trading system. Should that happen the biggest loser would be China, but that would blow-back to the entire global economy. Not a pretty picture. Moreover with Hillary Clinton now opposed to the TPP the outlook for trade expansion is far from favorable.
Too many people I know joke about Trump, but the fact remains has consistently led the GOP field and he has to be viewed as having at least a 50/50 shot of getting the nomination. We may not pay attention, but the rest of the world certainly is.
Labels:
China,
GOP,
presidential elections,
stock market,
TPP,
trade,
Trump
Saturday, January 2, 2016
An Open Letter to Trump and Cruz Voters in the Republican Primaries
Forgive me for saying this, but I think
you are being played. Both Trump and Cruz are tapping into our visceral dislike
of the very authoritarian nature of the elite liberals who control the White
House and who enforce political correctness throughout the media. It is the
authoritarian Obama White House that determines which laws to enforce and which
laws to ignore. Indeed it is President Obama who bypasses the Congress to
change immigration, environmental and gun laws and is so beholden to political
correctness that he refuses to call the radical Islamic terrorists for what
they are. It is more than enough to make you angry. But remember, anger is not
a policy.
So why am I so down on Trump and Cruz?
Plenty! They too are authoritarians who if elected would bend our laws to suit
their selfish ends. All we would be doing is substituting one set of
authoritarians with another. They are on the flip-side of the Obama coin. How
can a Putin worshiper like Trump be trusted with the presidency? Given the constitutional constraints on the
presidency, Trump, given his authoritarian nature, would become a very
frustrated bully lashing out at innocent civilians wherever he could find them.
His way of insulting his opponents is only a mere foretaste of what would come.
How can a Cruz be trusted with the
presidency when he has never led a team in his life and for that matter never
really played on a team? He has always been out for himself and that is why he
has no friends in the Senate. To him that is a badge of honor. However with
that attitude all of his ideas would be dead on arrival and he would be forced
to become another Obama by subverting the Constitution. He doesn’t understand
what Ronald Reagan knew deep in his bones that politics is the art of the
possible. Remember a leader needs followers willing to work with him. Indeed
both Cruz and Trump fail the most fundamental daycare test in the book. They
don’t play well with others.
So I ask you to think back to all of the
great presidents of the past. We may have different ideas of which were great,
but I would say does Cruz or Trump remind you of any of them. I doubt it. So
you are being played. First by the candidates and second by their cheerleaders
on talk radio and the internet who are lusting for power and ratings. For our
country’s sake find someone else to support. Otherwise you will end up with not
King Trump or King Cruz, but rather with Queen Hillary who might luxuriate with
a Democratic House and Senate that a Trump or Cruz candidacy might just bring
about. Although “stick it to the man” politics may feel good, trust me, it will
end badly.
Labels:
Barack Obama,
Donald Trump,
immigration,
Putin,
Republican Party,
Ronald Reagan,
Ted Cruz
Friday, January 1, 2016
My Amazon Review of Ian Kershaw's "To Hell and Back: Europe 1914-1949"
The Wheels Come Off
The Europe of 1914, at least for its bourgeoisie,
represented the height of civilization, the “Belle Époque” if you will. And of a sudden the wheels fell off the track
and the continent plunged into the darkness The Great War. British historian
Ian Kershaw certainly proves George Kennan’s maxim that World War I was “the
great seminal catastrophe of the 20th Century.” The war arose in the
milieu of ethnic nationalism, territorial revisionism and increasing class
conflict growing out of mass industrialization. These three factors would
remain long after the war ended and into this pot would be thrown the crisis in
capitalism induced by the Great Depression.
Also arising out of the war was the
successful Bolshevik Revolution that sent chills down the spines of the
conservative elite. To Kershaw this was the most important event of the 20th
Century because the very real fear of communism made opposition to the rise of
fascism far more difficult in the West. It hardened the right and split the
left.
As a result the crisis in capitalism forced
politics to the right rather than the left which is not too much different from
what happened post-2008. Thus the West’s response to the rise of fascism was
timid, to say the least with respect to Germany’s re-occupation of the
Rhineland in 1936, the Spanish Civil War and the dismemberment of Czechoslovakia
in 1938. All the while the great purge trials were going on in Moscow.
Kershaw’s view of this history seems
more deterministic than say that of Zara Steiner’s. To him there is more or
less a straight-line between the Versailles settlements to the start of World
War II. To be sure he gives credit to “the
spirit of Locarno,” but not enough in my opinion. He also leaves out two chance
events that may have altered history. The first is outside his topic and that
was the premature death of New York Federal Reserve President in 1928. Had he
lived, in the minds of more than a few economists the worst effects of the
Great Depression might have been avoided. Within his bailiwick was again the
premature death of German Foreign Minister Gustav Stresemann in October 1929. If
there ever were a German politician who could have stopped Hitler, it was
Stresemann.
Kershaw brings the holocaust to the
forefront in Hitler’s war of annihilation in the East in his coverage of World
War II. Simply put Hitler wanted to conquer the West, but he wanted to destroy
the East. He almost succeeded.
Kershaw finishes his book with the
beginnings of the postwar recovery, the role of the Marshall plan and the start
of the Cold War. By 1949 Europe is central to the Cold War between the U.S. and
the Soviet Union, but its power is but a shadow of its former self. Kershaw has
done an excellent job in portraying this epochal period that this review hardly
does justice to.
For the complete Amazon URL see:
Labels:
Cold War,
communism,
European history,
fascism,
George Kennan,
Great Depression,
Hitler,
Stalin,
World War 1,
World War II
Wednesday, December 16, 2015
The Fed Moves: At Last
Seven years ago today, in response to a very real financial emergency, the Fed embarked upon its zero interest rate policy. With the emergency long over the Fed finally acted by raising the federal funds rate by 25 basis points. Because the rate rise was accompanied by very dovish comments the stock market rallied smartly and the bond market, which had correctly priced in the move, ended the day substantially unchanged.
There are three points to take note of:
1. Monetary policy remains extraordinarily accommodating. My analogy is that on a 65 mph speed limit highway, instead of going 90 mph the car has slowed down to a still excessive 85 mph. Thus today's move is unlikely to slow the economy and in fact with the Fed signalling that the emergency is over, the economy could very well speedup.
2. Markets are way too complacent about inflation. With the core CPI increasing at a 2% rate yoy it won't take much for the Fed's personal consumption deflator to be there as well. Moreover housing costs, health care and other services are reporting inflation rates well above 2%. Once oil prices stabilize and likely reverse their recent decline most of the ingredients will be in place for an upside surprise in the inflation data. Stay tuned!
3. If you closed your eyes and I told you that core inflation was 2%, the unemployment rate was 5%, GDP growth is above 2%, and the stock market is close to an all time high, what would you guess the fed funds rate to be? It would be quite a bit higher than .25%-.5%.
Net Net. Interest rates will surprise on the upside.
There are three points to take note of:
1. Monetary policy remains extraordinarily accommodating. My analogy is that on a 65 mph speed limit highway, instead of going 90 mph the car has slowed down to a still excessive 85 mph. Thus today's move is unlikely to slow the economy and in fact with the Fed signalling that the emergency is over, the economy could very well speedup.
2. Markets are way too complacent about inflation. With the core CPI increasing at a 2% rate yoy it won't take much for the Fed's personal consumption deflator to be there as well. Moreover housing costs, health care and other services are reporting inflation rates well above 2%. Once oil prices stabilize and likely reverse their recent decline most of the ingredients will be in place for an upside surprise in the inflation data. Stay tuned!
3. If you closed your eyes and I told you that core inflation was 2%, the unemployment rate was 5%, GDP growth is above 2%, and the stock market is close to an all time high, what would you guess the fed funds rate to be? It would be quite a bit higher than .25%-.5%.
Net Net. Interest rates will surprise on the upside.
Labels:
economy,
Federal Reserve,
inflation,
interest rates,
oil prices
Saturday, December 5, 2015
My Amazon Review of Eric Rauchway's "The Money Makers: How Roosevelt and Keynes Ended the Depression, Defeated Fascism, and Secured a Prosperous Peace"
Too Partisan to be Real History
UC Davis history professor Eric Rauchway
let his rabid partisanship get in the way of some of the real history that is
in his book. His cheer-leading is obvious in the subtitle and that should
clearly warn less biased readers. It is not so much what Rauchway left in, but
rather what he left out and in doing that he did a real disservice to his
readers.
What Rauchway leaves out is as follows:
1.
Although he
rightly blames the operation of the gold standard as one of the predominant causes
of the Great Depression, he fails to discuss how successful it was in spurring growth
in the five decades up to World War I.
2.
He fails to
emphasize the fact that it was the imbalances caused by the financing of World
War I that was the key element in the demise of the gold standard.
3.
He completely ignores
the “forgotten depression’ of 1920-21 where recovery was rapid absent most of
the Keynesian remedies that came later and he ignores the great prosperity of
the 1920s.
4.
He hails
President Roosevelt in his “blowing up” of the World Economic Conference in
1933, but fails to mention that far from being an internationalist, Roosevelt
was an isolationist. The fascists in Europe took note of America’s withdrawal
from the world.
5.
He characterizes
the 1936 Tri-Partite Agreement to stabilize the French Franc as the start of an
anti-Nazi coalition. Wrong! Although France was lost some gold following the
German reoccupation of the Rhineland, the real cause of the Franc’s collapse
was the popular front policies of Leon Blum which scared the living daylights
out of French Capital.
6.
He completely
ignores the fact that after all of the New Deal spending programs and the
Federal Reserve money printing, the economy remained mired in depression as
late as 1939.
7.
He makes way too
a big deal out of the congressional vote to join the IMF. The measure passed
both houses of Congress easily.
8.
Although he notes
that Assistant Treasury Secretary Harry Dexter White, Keynes' negotiating partner at Bretton Woods, was a Soviet spy, he doesn’t
take seriously the Soviet penetration into the highest circles in the New Deal.
9.
In his
glorification of managed currencies he fails to note the debacle that came
after Nixon closed the gold window in 1971. Further if you want a date to start
when the United States economy became “financialized” you can do a lot worse
than 1971. Whatever the real problems of the gold standard, it would certainly
have acted as a very real constraint on what we call “the shadow banking system”.
For readers who want a better
understanding of the Great Depression I would recommend much of the works of
Barry Eichengreen, Ben Bernanke and Peter Temin.
For the full Amazon URL see:
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)