This weekend came with a lengthy Wall Street Journal article on how Greece recovered from its fiscal collapse in the 2010-2015 period. (See: https://www.wsj.com/world/europe/greece-debt-today-aaffcb16?mod=world_lead_pos5, Paywall) It took three international bailout packages and a severe dose of austerity that included drastic spending cuts, increased taxation, increasing the pension age from 65 to 67, and a crackdown on rampant tax evasion. To be sure the economy went through the ringer, but today Greece is running the only fiscal surplus in Europe and is borrowing at rates below that of the United States.
We wrote about the Greek crisis in 2015 arguing that the
country needed the then German Chancellor Angela Merkel’s tough love. (See: https://shulmaven.blogspot.com/2015/07/greece-needs-merkels-tough-love.html
) Although it was difficult to accept at that time, the E.U bailout with all of
the required austerity mentioned above worked. Indeed, as we argued at at the
time, the E.U. kept its share of the bargain by stretching out the term of the
debt and lowering the interest rate.
Now what does this have to do with France? France
today is in a similar, albeit lesser plight, with a 5% deficit to GDP ratio and
with an ever-increasing pension burden. Just as in 2010 Greece, the French are
in the streets demanding even more benefits. Instead of increasing the pension
age the demonstrators want to lower it from 62 to 60. However, the cupboard is
bare.
The dilemma that France and Europe are facing is that France
is both too big to fail and too big to rescue. The rescue of Greece was
small potatoes compared to what a rescue of France would cost today. Further it
would be very hard for the Dutch electorate to fund paying pensions at age 62
for the French when their pension age is now on the road to 72.
Thus, as much a France needs to follow the Greek
course when all of Europe brought pressure bear on that small country, it doesn’t
seem likely there are politicians in Europe and France that have the will and
the stamina to make the hard choices that are necessary.