The Purim War- Part 8: Trump Capitulates

 As we noted in a prior post, Trump is completely transactional and has no loyalty to his ally Israel. (See: https://shulmaven.blogspot.com/2026/06/the-purim-war-part-7-israel-learns.html ) Little did we realize at the time how craven Trump would be with his capitulation to Iran. Trump has gone from “unconditional surrender” to practically whatever Iran wants. The 14-point Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) leaves open Iran’s nuclear program and enables them to continue their ballistic missile program. Indeed, the MOU calls the termination of the war in Lebanon without mentioning Hezbollah and without Israel being a signatory to the deal. Recall Israel entered the war cheek by jowl with the U.S. in the most coordinated inter-allied cooperation since World War II.

 

Perhaps more troubling is that Iran is now given sanctions relief to sell its oil on the market thereby funding the regime that is now desperate for cash. Although the deal keeps the Strait of Hormuz to be free from tolls for 60 days, it leaves open the very real possibility of tolls going forward. This is in complete contradiction to international law and America’s long held position on freedom of the seas. (See: Shulmaven: The Purim War- Part 5, Deadlock in the Strait of Hormuz* )

 

Put bluntly, in exchange for temporarily opening the Strait of Hormuz, which was wide open prior to the war, Iran has conceded nothing. To be sure, if Iran fails to move forward on eliminating its nuclear capacity, the U.S. reserves the right to resume the war.  Trump has threatened this, but his threat has zero credibility with the midterm elections just around the corner. What we have ended up with is something worse than Sherman-Malley-Obama-Biden deal of 2015.

 

In 1938, just after the Munich summit with Hitler, Winston Churchill called out Neville Chamberlain with the following:

 

   “You were given the choice between war and dishonour. You chose dishonour, and you will have war.”

 

I fear that instead of peace, Trump has set the stage for the next Iran War in the not-too-distant future.

The Purim War

 About 2,382 years ago Esther and Mordechai ousted the Jew-hater Haman, first minister of Persia; an event that is now celebrated as Purim by Jews all over the world. In an eerie coincidence Purim starts on Monday evening March 2^nd. This time, instead of Haman being killed, the bulk of the Iranian leadership including the Grand Ayatollah Khamenei was killed in precision airstrikes by the Israeli air force. The U.S./Israeli effort’s goal is to topple the Iranian regime that has long threatened the region and was yet again reconstituting its nuclear and missile programs. With Iranian negotiators practicing “rope-a-dope” tactics with U.S. negotiators, President Trump’s patience ran out, and he unleashed an air and naval armada on the Iranian regime.

 

My sense is that Trump’s logic was the Iranian regime was weakened by the mass protests against it in January triggered by its collapsing economy. The regime responded with brute force and killed anywhere between 30,000-50,000 people. As they say in China, the Iranian mullahs “lost their mandate from heaven.” It will now be up to the Iranian people to establish a new course.

 

What happens next depends on the staying power of the remnants of the regime and the willingness of the U.S. and Israel to sustain a long campaign. Meantime, by attacking U.S. bases in Saudi Arabia, Iran lost the neutrality of the Arab gulf further isolating them. The other thing to think about is whether or not Israel will take advantage of the situation to cleanup its unfinished business with Hezbollah and Hamas.

 

Of course, it goes without saying, the Democrats are up in arms against Trump making war without congressional authorization. However, a careful reading of the war powers act means that what Trump did, as commander in chief, was legal so far. However, he does have to report to Congress on the war, and Congress will have a say. My sense is that Iran 2026 is not Iraq of 2003 but then again time will tell. But make no mistake, the middle east will not be what it was as of last Friday.