My Review of David Brown's "A Hell of a Storm: The Battle for Kansas......."

 1854: The Hinge Year on the Road to Civil War

 

Historian David Brown has given us an important and very readable book on how the events of 1854 set America on course to our civil war. The critical event was the passage of the Kansas-Nebraska Act which broke the Missouri Compromise of 1820 by allowing the territories north of 36 degrees 30 minutes latitude to decide for themselves whether or not they wanted to allow slavery under the doctrine of popular sovereignty. Prior to that enactment slavery was prohibited in most of the Louisiana Purchase. The notion of popular sovereignty was first introduced by Senator Stephen Douglas in the 1850 compromise that brought California into the Union, but, allowed for the New Mexico and Arizona Territories to vote on whether or not they wanted slavery. Stephen Douglas would then build on the 1850 compromise to champion the Kansas-Nebraska Act.

 

The notion of popular sovereignty seems quaint today, but I would note we are yet again living with this on the issue of abortion. The overturning of Rowe v. Wade returned the question of abortion to the states where each state would determine how it deals with this question.

 

Leading the charge against the Kansas-Nebraska Act was Free Soil Party Senator Salmon P. Chase. Chase would go on to help found the new Republican Party in 1854, become Lincoln’s Secretary of the Treasury, and then become Chief Justice of the Supreme Court. His leadership on this issue established him as a national figure and the issue brought Abraham Lincoln out of his successful law practice into the national limelight. The growing chasm between north and south was occurring against the backdrop of rising industrialization and a growing abolition movement. It would become a battle between free labor and slavery.

 

So great was the controversy over the act, that the Whig Party would collapse as the northern Whigs could no longer countenance being in the same party as the southern Whigs. Most of the northern Whigs became Republicans and the Democrats solidified their position in the South and picked up those northern Whigs who didn’t become Republicans. The reason why the act passed was because the slavery-oriented Democratic Party was at the height of its power controlling the presidency and both houses of Congress. Indeed the New Hampshire native Franklin Pierce was the last Democratic president to receive a majority vote for president until Franklin Roosevelt in 1932.

 

Brown brings into the mix Harriet Beecher Stowe of “Uncle Tom’s Cabin” fame published in 1852, Henry David Thoreau and his “Walden Pond” (1854), and Harriet Tubman’s underground railroad. All of this was going on in and around 1854. Further, in 1854 the full ramifications of the Fugitive Slave Law, part of the 1850 compromise, was being felt in the North, especially Massachusetts.

 

David Brown gives us a very real sense of our country heading towards civil war. Unfortunately, the parallels for today are more than disquieting.

My Thoughts on the First Anniversary of October 7th

 There are many dates that are seared into our memory.  President Roosevelt, responding to the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, called December 7^th, 1941,” a date which will live in infamy” and demanded a declaration of war against Japan. December 7^th,1941, resonates with me because that was that was the day my Dad proposed to my Mom in Central Park.  Four days later Hitler asked for and received a declaration of war from the Reichstag against the United States. Sitting in the audience cheering him on was Amin al-Husseini, the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem. Yes, the antagonism between Jews and Palestinians predates 1948 and 1967. Indeed, well before 1941.

 

On September 11^th, 2001, Al-Qaeda crashed two airplanes into the World Trade Center towers and one plane into the Pentagon, killing nearly 3,000 people. I witnessed the attack on the towers from across the street.

 

Today, we memorialize another date, October 7^th, 2023, Israel’s, and World Jewry’s day of infamy. On that day 1200 hundred people in Israel’s Gaza envelope died and 240 were kidnapped by the Hamas terrorists. To put this event into perspective 1200 dead in Israel is equivalent to 40,000 dead in the United States.

 

Now, a year later, a war rages on in Gaza and Lebanon testing whether Israel, a light unto the nations, can remain true to its founding as a democratic home to the Jewish people. It is a war where about 725 soldiers, who in the words of Abraham Lincoln “gave the last full measure of devotion.”

 

It is my hope that “these dead have not died in vain.” (Again, from Lincoln) Just as our Civil War can be viewed as the second American revolution, so too can Israel’s war in Gaza and Lebanon be viewed as its second war of independence. And it is my hope the war will midwife a new generation of Israeli leadership that will have the wisdom to rise above the country’s divisive internal politics and find a path to seek peace with its neighbors.

My Review of Nicholas Meyer's "Sherlock Holmes and the Telegram from Hell"

 Sherlock Holmes in His Majesty’s Service

 

Nicholas Meyer has reincarnated himself as Arthur Conan Doyle. His 1974 “The 7% Solution” was a bestseller and later a motion picture. From there he has written several novels in the tradition of Sherlock Holmes. His latest involves his hiring by Britain’s MI-6 at the height of World War I in 1916. His mission is to obtain a secret telegram sent by the German foreign office to Mexico’s president Carranza. The mission would challenge a younger Holmes and Watson, but here we see them it what is likely to be the last case of their lives.

 

Of course, any reader with a knowledge of history would realize that the telegram in question is the Zimmermann Telegram where Germany offered help to Mexico to seize most of what it lost in the Mexican War of 1848, namely Texas, Arizona, and New Mexico.  Britain needed to expose the telegram in order to bring America into the war.

 

In order to complete their mission Holmes and Watson journey to Washington D.C., and Mexico. In Washington they meet up with Alice Roosevelt Longworth, Teddy’s youngest daughter, who was having an affair with the German ambassador. This part is not true, but she did have an adventurous sex life and had a long running affair with Senator William Borah. Her husband Nicholas would be Speaker of the House from 1925-1931. Alice is helpful in that she puts Holmes on the trail to Mexico.

 

In Mexico, with the aide of a communist housekeeper, Holmes comes up with the telegram and escapes Mexico via a British destroyer sent especially for him and Watson. Along the way there are attempts on Holmes’ life on the ship to the U.S., in Washington D.C., and in Mexico. It seems that the Germans were not oblivious to his mission.

 

I had a lot of fun reading this book. It was a pleasure to catch up to the great detective as Meyer does Doyle justice.