The Coming Global Disorder
Peter Zeihan “end of the world” thesis is based on the
demography of collapsing birthrates and the globalization we have been living
with since the 1944 Bretton Woods agreement is in terminal free fall. To him,
the era of “order” is over and will soon be remembered as an aberration. I
agree with him with respect to global demographics, but, although weakening,
globalization will still be with us. Of course, if Zeihan’s view of the end of
globalization is correct, the world as we know it will be in a world of hurt.
Simply put, much of the world has benefitted from the
international division of labor brought about by the monetary stability of
Bretton Woods and the presence of the U.S. Navy protecting freedom of the seas
for all of the participants in the global economy. Instead of pirates trawling
the seas, we have giant container ships bringing a harvest of goods to global
producers and consumers.
Zeihan adopts a neo-Trumpian view of global trade
where the U.S. worker has subsidized the rest of the world and as a result the
U.S. will withdraw from the global economy no longer interested in enforcing
international norms. Thus, with the unity of the Cold War struggle with the
Soviet Union over, the support of Western Europe and East Asia less important.
Less important, maybe; irrelevant not quite.
Where Zeihan is on much sounder footing is his
discussion of demographics. Both Russia and China along with most of Europe and
northeast Asia are rapidly depopulating. Simply put, the world is getting older
at a very rapid pace and will soon be without workers. Watching Russia and
China grow old might not be so benign for the world, because I fear that their
leaders understand this and are in the process of expanding their reach before
it is too late. Hence Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and China’s increasing
aggressiveness over Taiwan. Further Zeihan under-rates the capabilities of the
Chinese navy.
Zeihan goes into great detail in discussing global
transportation, finance, energy industrial materials, manufacturing, and
agriculture. In the case of the last the end of globalization will bring with
it the prospect of mass starvation. During World War I the Central Powers were
cut off from global agricultural trade bringing with it mass starvation.
According to Zeihan the United States, because of
better demographics, its resource base and proximity to both Canada and Mexico
is in far better shape than the rest of the world. To be sure the U.S. would
end up poorer, but compared to the rest we would be looking pretty. Of course,
a war with Russia or China would radically alter this picture.
Zeihan has a breezy writing style making the book easy
to read. My guess is that he is directionally right, but he over-states his
case.
For the full Amazon URL see: The Coming World Disorder (amazon.com)
No comments:
Post a Comment