Wednesday, March 6, 2019

My Amazon Review of Adam Higginbotham's "Midnight in Chernobyl: The Untold Story of the World's Greatest Nuclear Disaster"


Meltdown

Adam Higginbotham’s account of the meltdown of RBMK Reactor #4 at Chernobyl and its aftermath for the most part reads like fast-paced thriller that keeps wanting you to turn the next page. Using secondary sources and direct interviews over a period of decade with many of the principals involved, the author gets you into the heads of the decision makers and the thought process that led to the meltdown and the subsequent cover-up.

On April 25th 1986 a failed safety test triggered the meltdown of Reactor #4. Radiation immediately spewed into the surrounding town of Pripyat, which was built to support the Chernobyl reactor complex. As an aside some of the heaviest fighting during World War II took place in the nearby Pripyat marshes. All of the staff at the nuclear power station lived in the town with their families. It took several days before an evacuation order was given and in nearby Kiev the planned outdoor celebration of May Day took place as radiation from the failed reactor rained down on the residents.

Higginbotham takes you very deep into the nuclear science of atomic reactors and the nature of the radiation that was leaked during and after the meltdown. At points this is heavy going, but I believe it is necessary to tell the story. Because the real story was not so much the meltdown, but the associated radiation. He tells a riveting tale of the Russian helicopter pilots dropping sand and boron into the reactor to cool it. The pilots were at enormous personal risk and in the end their brave efforts did little to cool the reactor.

The author also takes you into Moscow Hospital #6 where many of the radiation sickness patients were treated and he follows their treatment protocols. Of course most of them die, but there were several survivors that he interviewed at length.

Of course Higginbotham saves his wrath, not for the power plant operators who were put on trial for the reactor failure, but rather for the entire Soviet system that allowed inherently unsafe reactors to be put online in the first place. Simply put a major nuclear accident at an RMKB reactor was inevitable because of inherent design flaws and the faulty construction that was endemic. The Soviet system both before and during the Stagnation Period under Brezhnev could not admit failure. Both the political and scientific bureaucracies were ossified and defensive. And by the time Gorbachev arrived in 1985 the Russian people had little faith in the system.

Thus as the full horror of Chernobyl became known it became obvious that the Soviet government cared little for its citizenry and if you like you can draw a straight line from Chernobyl to the dissolution of the Soviet Union.  But I end on a word of caution; we here in the U.S. are not exempt from cover-ups. I will only cite the deception given by New York City officials that the post 9/11 air quality south of Canal Street was safe to breathe. It wasn’t.





Wednesday, February 27, 2019

The Republican Moral Eunuchs and the Magnificent 13

Yesterday the House approved a resolution of disapproval on President Trump's "national emergency" to fund his border wall by a vote of 245-182. Simply put Trump usurped the power of Congress by declaring his intention to spend $5.6 billion that was previously rejected by the Congress. 182 Republicans voted against the resolution that had President Obama done a similar thing not only would they have voted for the resolution they would have immediately started impeachment proceedings. To my mind these Republicans are moral eunuchs and deserve to be defeated in the 2020 election. They failed to uphold their oaths office to support and defend the Constitution, especially Article I which gives Congress the power of the purse.

However, standing up intense pressure from the White House and Leader  Kevin McCarthy 13 Republican Representatives voted for the resolution. I call them the magnificent 13.  They are libertarian Justin Amash (MI), Brian Fitzpatrick (PA), Mike Gallagher (WI), Jaime Herrera Beutler (WA), former CIA agent Will Hurd (TX), Dusty Johnson (SD), Thomas Massie (KY),former leadership member Cathy McMorris Rodgers (WA), Francis Rooney (FL),
veteran member Jim Sensenbrenner (WI), rising star Elise Stefanik NY), veteran member Fred Upton (MI) and former leadership member Greg Walden (OR). These magnificent 13 members ought to be complimented and financially supported in future elections.

Let's hope the Republican members of the Senate have more backbone than their House counterparts and vote to support the resolution of disapproval when they vote in a few weeks.

Monday, February 25, 2019

My Amazon Review of Laurence Leamer's "Mar-A-Lago: Inside the Gates of Power at Donald Trump's Presidential Palace"


The Sun King

Writer and Palm Beach resident Laurence Leamer has written a very breezy and gossipy history of Donald Trump’s involvement with Mar-a-Lago and through that he confirms pretty much all we know about Donald Trump. He starts with Trump’s enchantment with the Mar-a Lago estate that was formerly owned by the heiress, Marjorie Merriweather Post. Trump buys the asset for about $10 million dollars with only $300,000 of his own money. Not bad for an asset that has been much improved could now be worth $500 million.

Trump’s entrance on to the Palm Beach scene shakes that the then very stuffy community to its very foundations. He doesn’t play by the rules, sues the town many times over zoning issues and he ultimately gets his way. Where Trump does some real good he breaks the anti-Semitism of that insular community with the aid of his Jewish lawyer Paul Rampell. By the way it was Rampell’s idea to convert the estate to a club.

Leamer has obviously walked the halls of Mar-a-Lago where he has keen sense for detail and Trump’s obsession with gold. He has talked with many members and employees who tell tales of Trump’s mercurial temper, especially with his employees. To call him mean and rotten would be an understatement. But make no mistake, Trump is the Sun King of Mar-a-Lago.

Trump’s affair and later marriage to Marla Maples is a highlight of this book. Here Leamer notes that Trump did whatever he could to prevent being known that Maples had sex with one his body guards on the beach. After Maples there is, of course, Melania and their 2005 wedding was the highlight of the social season and Trump paid for it by selling the photography rights.

We also encounter the National Enquirer and Trump’s buddy Christopher Ruddy of the rightwing website Newsmax.  Leamer’s thesis is that the Donald Trump we see today was honed in the hothouse of Palm Springs. Leamer’s book isn’t great history, but it is a fun read.




Wednesday, February 20, 2019

The Real Losers in NYC’s Amazon Loss


Much has been written about Amazon pulling the plug on its planned HQ2 in New York City and with that about 25,000 high paying jobs (See my thoughts at https://shulmaven.blogspot.com/2019/02/amazon-to-new-york-drop-dead.html). The millennial socialist Congresswoman Alexandra Ocaisio-Cortez whooped it up when Amazon made its announcement.

But who were the real losers? The losers are the very millennials she pretends to represent. Why? Although Amazon would have hired people from all over the country a decent chunk of them would come from current and recent graduates of the City University of New York (CUNY). For those of you who don’t know CUNY is a vast system of 275,000 students that includes 11 senior colleges. Most of the students are first in their family to go to college, immigrants and children of immigrants. They are real strivers trying to better themselves. As an aside Amazon would have offered opportunity for the graduates of the Bronx High School of Science and Stuyvesant, two great specialized high schools, the opportunity to work in NYC upon college graduation instead of moving on to Silicon Valley, Austin or Boston. Another real loss for the city.

A few friends of mine have argued that Amazon would not hire CUNY graduates. Nothing can be further from the truth. Google, Amazon and Facebook are already hiring CUNY graduates and if the Amazon deal went through they would have hired a boatload more.

I know from experience when I helped set up the Financial Leadership Program at Baruch College (a CUNY school) in 2006 to prepare students for Wall Street careers. The naysayers said Wall Street would never hire Baruch graduates for front office positions. Today, 13 years later there are Baruch grads all over Wall Street at such firms as JP Morgan, Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, Merrill Lynch and in several private equity shops.  With the impetus coming from Amazon CUNY’s beachhead position with the major tech firms would have dramatically expanded.

But alas it will take longer; thanks to the misguided efforts of the so-called tribunes of the people. It is a real crime to steal the hopes and dreams of so many young people and those who led the charge against Amazon should be severely punished at the ballot box.

Tuesday, February 19, 2019

My Amazon Review of Roger McNamee's "Zucked: Waking Up to the Facebook Catastrophe"


Move Fast and Break Things

Roger McNamee, a Silicon Valley venture capitalist and part-time rock musician who hangs out with Bono, has levelled an indictment against Facebook. As an early investor in Facebook McNamee has seen the company from the inside as it moved fast to become a mega-cap colossus that is now playing a major part in breaking our democracy. He mentored Mark Zuckerberg and helped broker Sheryl Sandberg’s move from Google to Facebook. And as he notes he has not had meaningful contact with them for several years. Perhaps he is not telling us something about his relationships with them.

Simply put Facebook is in the business of manipulating its users through artificial intelligence to spend more and more time on the website thereby generating huge advertising dollars. Facebook then sells its user data to advertisers, some of whom were Russian cutouts seeking to elect Donald Trump.

To McNamee the worst aspect of social media in general and Facebook in particular is that it makes it far too easy for people to silo themselves into groups with similar interests and beliefs. When that happens political polarization occurs where people only hear what they want to hear in a self-reinforcing mechanism. Because Facebook is almost frictionless it easily conveys misinformation that the silo-heads believe to be true. To paraphrase Mark Twain from a much earlier era, “a lie races half way around the world before the truth puts its shoes on.”

Aside from being a venture capitalist and a musician, McNamee is a political junkie of the liberal democratic variety. His use of the term “neo-liberal” is a “tell.” Over the past few years he has spent quite a bit of time with the California congressional delegation, including Speaker Nancy Pelosi. He also briefed both House and Senate panels ahead of Zuckerberg’s testimony.

McNamee’s solution to the problems is stricter antitrust enforcement. He wails against the Chicago School of antitrust regulation. He would also prefer a subscription model a la Netflix to the current advertising model. Both are good ideas.

Where I would differ with McNamee is his view that the internet was all wonderful until the technological revolution of wider bandwidth, cloud computing and smart phones came along that enabled social media. Perhaps he conveniently forgets that the early internet was built on porn and the secure payment processing system that came with it.

In the interests of full disclosure I do not have a Facebook account, but I do have Twitter and LinkedIn accounts, use Google a lot, and check my smart phone way too often. I too am addicted.





Thursday, February 14, 2019

Amazon to New York: Drop Dead*

Amazon pulled the plug on its commitment to build its HQ2 in the Long Island City neighborhood of New York City. Although city residents broadly supported the project, there was a very vocal local opposition with Alexandra Ocasio Cortez one of the leaders. It takes a lot of gall to say No to 25000 clean high paying jobs, but NYC did just that. Too bad.

By jerking Amazon around the city sent a message that it simply doesn’t care about jobs. Trust me the economic after shocks are going to be nontrivial.

* With apologies to the New York Daily News for its famous 1975 headline “Ford to New York: Drop Dead”

Monday, February 11, 2019

Amy Klobuchar: A Unifying Democrat

Minnesota Senator Amy Klobuchar declared her candidacy for the Democratic presidential nomination yesterday in the snowy bitter cold of the upper Midwest. What impressed me most about her speech was the following statement: "E pluribus unum. Out of many one. It is more than a motto. It is the North Star of our democracy. It is the North Star of this effort." After watching the Democratic Party gorge itself on the disunity of identity politics, Klobuchar offers us breath of fresh air rising above the pettiness of our politics today.

I don't know how far her candidacy will go, but from her Senate career we know that she is a work horse, not a show horse and we know she knows how to get things done. She was the only senator to come out of the Kavanaugh hearing with an enhanced reputation. I would hope that the Democratic primary electorate takes her very seriously, because in my opinion she and her unifying vision has the best shot at defeating Trump.