Showing posts with label investing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label investing. Show all posts

Friday, July 20, 2018

My Amazon Review of Seth Klarman's "Margin of Safety: Risk -Averse Value Investing"


A Primer on Value Investing

Seth Klarman through his Baupost Fund is one of the greatest investors of the current generation, perhaps of all-time. This 1991 book is an investing classic, so much so that it sells for $780 on the secondary market. The key insight for most value investors is the all investments must have an inherent margin of safety. That means looking at the downside before looking at the upside. The notion of risk is asymmetric, not the standard deviation of returns as modern portfolio theory suggests. For example for any given stock under modern portfolio risk is independent of price; for a value investor risk is extraordinarily dependent upon price.

Klarman is focused on absolute performance, not relative performance. Thus unlike the bubbleheads on CNBC he doesn’t have to be invested all of the time. He is rightly skeptical of Wall Street research and the exotic products their investment bankers come up with.

The key earnings metric for Klarman is rightly free cash flow. It is not earnings per share and it is not EBITDA. Depreciation is real and so too are capital expenditures which do not enter the income statement.

The reader has to remember that this book was written in 1991 against the backdrop of the 1987 crash, the junk bond collapse and the 1990 bear market. He is critical of newly issued junk bonds (high yield in today’s terminology). Little did he realize that 27 years later high yield would dominate the new issues. He is also critical of the index funds that now dominate today’s stock market. For the average investor index funds make a great deal of sense.

Why? Simply put the average investor doesn’t have the talent or the time to be a value investor like Klarman. To be another Seth Klarman takes more than a few brains and much hard work.

“Margin of Safety” is written in clear and concise language. My two criticisms are that there are far too few examples of value investing in action and it is obviously dated. Nevertheless the lessons to be learned from reading the book are timeless.





Sunday, June 24, 2018

My Amazon Review of Michael Batnick's "Big Mistakes: The Best Investors and their Worst Investments"


Learning from the Mistakes of Others

Michael Batnick, the research director at Ritholtz Wealth Management, is teaching us that it is important to learn from the mistakes from some of the most successful investors of all-time. This is not an original concept, but nonetheless it as an important one. Nevertheless my problem with his book is not with Batnick, but with his editors or his lack of editors. There are typos, math errors and outright mistakes (e.g. calling “Supermoney” author Jerry Goodman, Jerry Goodwyn.) Further it would have been very helpful to have stock charts where they would have been relevant.

That said he points out the most common of errors all of us have, even the great ones, in that we are victims of hubris/overconfidence, we get sucked in by the allure of leverage and out of frustration we invest outside of our circle of competence. His many examples include, Jack Bogle, Michael Steinhardt,  Stanley Druckenmiller, John Paulson, the Sequoia Fund, Long Term Capital Management, Bill Ackman and yes, Warren Buffett. In Buffett’s case Batnick believes Buffett became overconfident based on his prior experience in investing in the shoe business with his purchase of Dexter Shoe in the early 1990s. He compounded his mistake by paying in stock that would become more valuable over time only to see the business ravaged by foreign competition.

In cases of Paulson, Druckenmiller and Steinhardt we see them investing beyond their core competencies and the case of Bill Ackman we his very big ego get in the way with his giant short position in Herbalife. Of course leverage and hubris brings down Long Term Capital Management. These are all wonderful vignettes and there is much to learn, but I wish Batnick had a sharp penciled editor.






Wednesday, October 8, 2014

Calpers Makes the Top

The Wall Street Journal reported today that the giant $300 billion California Public Employees Retirement System (Calpers) will increase its real estate allocation from $26 billion to $33 billion. It is not news that commercial real estate prices have surged and are now well above the frothy peak or early 2007. Just as in the late 1980s and and in 2005-2007 it appears that Calpers is weighing in at the top of the market.

Recall that Calpers bought the California land play Catellus and the UK property company Randsworth Trust at the peak of the late 1980s real estate boom. Those investments, to say the least, soured. In 2007 Calpers bought into the giant and highly leveraged Stuyvesant Town apartment project in Manhattan as de-rent control play. Like Randsworth Trust that investment was a wipe-out.

To be sure one can say that Calpers has learned from their previous episodes. This time it will be concentrating on lower risk "core" assets that have become extraordinarily pricey in the global search for yield. Therefore the risk here is very straight forward, cap rates could rise. Basically to take a major position in commercial real estate today the investor has to believe that cap rates will remain low for a decade. To me this could be the riskiest bet of all. After all more money has been lost in the search for yield than in practically any other investment endeavor.

As a result real estate investors should be forewarned. It looks like, yet again, Calpers will be making another top.

Thursday, October 24, 2013

My Amazon Review of Mark Spitznagel's, "The Dao of Capital: Austrian Investing in a Distorted World"

Money manager Mark Spitznagel has written a very wordy paean to Austrian Economics. If ever a book needed a tight fisted editor this one is it. However, once you get beyond reading every thing Spitznagel knows about Austrian Economics the reader will get a better understanding of economics and the investment process. The key takeaways from the book are the core notions of Austrian Economics which value roundabout(indirect) production over direct production and the role of monetary policy to distort investment decisions. For example, in the case of the former, the direct route to catching a fish would be to try to grab one in a pond while the roundabout and far more profitable route would be to make a net first and then use it to catch fish. In case of the latter, the low interest policy of the Federal Reserve induces investment that will be proved unprofitable once interest rates normalize leading to a bust. This knowledge leads investors to hedge tail risks when the stock market trades at high price/replacement cost ratios and to buy individual stocks that with high returns on capital that won't be affected by increases in interest rates. Nothing really new here, but puts some real foundation underneath it. That is the value of the book.

Spitznagel uses the biographies of the three great Austrian economists, Carl Menger Eugen von Bohm-Bawerk and Ludvig von Mises to explain Austrian economic theory. All of that is to the good, but he leaves out perhaps the greatest Austrian economists of all time, Joseph Schumpeter and Friedrich von Hayek. I guess Schumpeter's and Hayek's work don't quite fit into his theories. He also ignores the work of three American economists who built on the work of the Austrians: Irving Fisher, Frank Knight and Jack Hirshleifer, a former professor of mine. For example Hirshleifer, in his "Investment, Interest and Capital" outlines a general equilibrium approach to interest rate determination with a society's rate of time preference and an intertemporal production possibilities function, pure Austrian economics.

The full Amazon URL is:http://www.amazon.com/The-Dao-Capital-Investing-Distorted-ebook/product-reviews/B00D7P2K1W/ref=cm_cr_pr_hist_3?ie=UTF8&filterBy=addThreeStar&showViewpoints=0&sortBy=bySubmissionDateDescending