Tuesday, July 7, 2026

My Review of Randall Sullivan's "The First All-Star Game"

 All-Stars


On July 14th baseball will celebrate the 93rd anniversary of the first All-Star Game to be held in Philadelphia. Here Randall Sullivan recounts the history of how the first All-Star game came to be along with digressions about the history of baseball, the Great Depression, The Negro Leagues, Franklin Roosevelt, Chicago politics, and the gangsters of the 1930’s. As a kid growing up in the 1950’s, I ate, drank, and slept baseball. I read all kinds of sanitized books about the early years of baseball and the great players of that era.

 

As Sullivan notes, the origin of the first All-Star game in 1933 had its roots in the Chicago Tribune and its sports editor, Arch Ward. With the country in depression there was a special need to hype up the 1933 Chicago World’s Fair. The idea came to Ward to have the “game of the century” that would feature the best players in the National and American leagues playing against each other with the players to be selected by a vote of the fans. To pull this event off it required the support of both league presidents, the Kenesaw Mountain Landis, the Commissioner of Baseball, Chicago Mayor Edward Kelly, and the support of President Roosevelt.

 

It worked and it all came together with Connie Mack, the manager of the then Philadelphia Athletics, and John McGraw, the manager of the then New York Giants piloting each team of all-stars. Of course, the great Babe Ruth played for the American League and let his team to a 4-2 victory with a home run.

 

I learned much about the players of that era. They weren’t quite the all-American choir boys, except for the great Lou Gehrig, they were portrayed in the books that I read those many years ago. For example, instead of coming out of an orphanage to play baseball, Babe Ruth was in reform school. He also had a gluttonous taste for food, booze, and women. He was a customer of brothels in every American League city. Nevertheless, after a night of carousing, he was still among the greatest of all time on the field and at bat.

 

My quarrel with the book is that Sullivan goes off on to many tangents that can lose the reader’s interest. Nevertheless, he tells a story of how baseball captured America’s imagination in the 1920’s with Babe Ruth along with Charles Lindberg being the two great celebrities of the Roaring 20’s.

 

No comments:

Post a Comment