The Fed's "Coup de Whisky" to the Stock Market

 Last week’s 50 basis point cut in the federal funds rate to 4.875% served up a “coup de whisky” to the stock market. Those words were spoken in July 1927 by Benjamin Strong, President of the New York Fed to Charles Rist, the Deputy Director of the Bank of France at secret central bank meeting on Long Island.* Much like today the U.S. economy was humming along, but Britain was rapidly losing gold. To take the pressure off the British Pound, Strong and several other regional banks cut the discount rate from 4% to 3.5%.

 

In response an already strong stock market was off to the races and would double over the next two years. That move put the roar in the roaring twenties. Although today’s circumstances are far different, but not so different; the economy is at roughly full employment, real GDP has likely grown at a 3% clip over the past six months, and inflation remains moderately above the Fed’s 2% target. Nevertheless, just like 1927 stocks roared in response to new highs.

 

The Fed’s move and it signals of further cuts of 100-150 basis points over the next nine months, is a bright green light for the stock market as investors now believe that the risk of recession is off the table and faster growth will ratify the very optimistic profits estimates for next year. I don’t think that we will repeat the late 1920’s blow-off but further new highs in stock prices appear likely.

 

Interestingly the yield on longer maturities increased. Why? On the margin the 50bp cut will increase both growth and inflation. The lower short-term interest rates will support corporate borrowing and auto finance. Housing, on the other hand, won’t be helped all that much because mortgage rates responding to higher long rates actually increased. That will force house buyers into variable rate paper.

 

The real risk in the Fed’s move is that inflation will not be as quiescent as it now believes. Simply put, the rate-cutting cycle that the market is banking on might be cut short.

* For a full discussion of this event see Ahamed, Liaquat, "The Lords of Finance" (New York: The Penguin Press, 2009) pp. 290-304